Review by Ron Fassler . . .
Walk into the James Earl Jones Theatre for the new musical Wanted and you’re greeted by a curtain styled as a wanted poster for two outlaws, Martha and Mary Clarke. They’re based on the great-great aunts of the show’s book writer and lyricist, Angelica Chéri, who explains in a dry pre-show announcement that while the story draws on family lore, much of it is simply made up. The opening number winks at the same idea, as the six-member chorus, billed as “Kinfolk,” sings: “But you know how family stories do, so we believe the story is mostly true.”
There’s nothing wrong with that approach, but the tale Chéri has chosen could use a dose more imagination, and more logic, than it gets. The book is the weak spot in an otherwise rip-roaring show set to sensational music by Ross Baum. The singing is roof-raising, and director Stevie Walker-Webb, new to me, brings dynamic energy to a beautifully mounted production. And hey, it’s an original musical, which earns bonus points all around.
Originally titled Gun & Powder (Wanted is better, if a tad generic), the show played Virginia’s Signature Theatre in 2020 and New Jersey’s Paper Mill Playhouse in 2024, runs successful enough to persuade a phalanx of producers to bring it to New York. Anti-heroes aren’t new to musicals, but Black women passing for white in 1890s Texas make for an arresting duo.

Twins Mary (Solea Pfeiffer) and Martha (Liisi LaFontaine) are the daughters of a struggling single mother, Tallulah (Melody A. Betts, filling in for Grammy winner Ledisi the day I saw it). In the post-emancipation South, picking cotton is, sadly, the family business, and the pay is meager. When the plantation’s owner (Nathan Quay Thomas) reneges on a promised piece of land and then raises Tallulah’s payment, the twins decide that the way to set things right is to rob the society that has wronged them. Outlaws are born, though decidedly inexperienced ones, which allows for some comedy along the way. Then Elijah (Bradley Dean), another plantation owner, discovers who the women really are but falls for Mary anyway, happy to have an outlaw for a girlfriend or even a bride. Of course, the bigoted fellow has no idea he’s fallen for a Black woman.
Numerous plot holes muddy both the sequence of events and the progression of the characters’ arcs. A musical can be forgiven some inconsistency, since suspension of disbelief is built in (no one bursts into song in real life), but audiences shouldn’t have to scratch their heads wondering whether what they’re watching makes sense. Take just one example: the women powder their faces to appear white, yet when Mary is half-naked in bed with her new husband, how does he not notice the difference? Better to have dropped the powder altogether and made the sisters extremely light-skinned. Or consider how the pair manage to stay so close to home as outlaws without everyone recognizing them. They’re wanted, after all!
Solea Pfeiffer, who has already built a strong Broadway presence in Almost Famous, Moulin Rouge!, and Hadestown, is a remarkable singer and actress. She shares lovely chemistry with Liisi LaFontaine as her sister Martha, who has charm and charisma for days and one hell of a singing voice (this is her Broadway debut, and a welcome one). Once again, an understudy going on proves to be a gift: Melody A. Betts was excellent as Tallulah. Betts usually plays the lead singer in the Kinfolk chorus, which meant her understudy, Crystal Joy, stepped into that role and was outstanding. All of the Kinfolk are marvelous singers and dancers, acing Chelsey Arce’s rich choreography. Special attention must also be paid to the comic-relief maids played by Aurelia Williams and Awa Sal Secka, who are exceptionally funny. The show comes alive whenever they’re front and center.

Baum’s score for Wanted makes me eager for a cast recording. It’s pleasing to the ear and offers far more than twangy Southern comfort. Chéri’s lyrics, though not as original as the music, are better than what passes for lyric writing on Broadway these days. John Clancy’s orchestrations are also impressive, and Baum shares credit for the arrangements with Austin Cook.
Beowulf Boritt brings his customary genius to the scenic design, with wooden arches and beams that glide about to conjure different settings. Emilio Sosa’s costumes are wildly entertaining, if often anachronistic, a choice that oddly works. Adam Honoré’s lighting and Stefania Bulbarella’s video and projection design add atmospheric delight.
The audience at the Saturday matinee I attended whooped and hollered, and it was a hoot and a half to join the cacophony. If you’re looking for a rootin’-tootin’ Western musical, something not all that easy to find, saddle up and trot on over to the James Earl Jones Theatre. Wanted is a heck of a lot of fun.
At the James Earl Jones Theatre, 138 W 48th Street, NYC. For futher information, visit Wanted.
Photos by Julieta Cervantes.
Headline photo: The Kinfolk of Wanted.
