By Alix Cohen

For those of you living under a rock: It’s a Wonderful Life is the heartwarming tale of George Bailey, a kindhearted man who’s spent his life putting the needs of others before his own. When financial troubles leave him feeling hopeless, an angel named Clarence shows the hero what life would have been like if he’d never been born.

George discovers how deeply he’s touched the lives of those around him. He learns that the true value of life lies in love, friendship, family, and the positive difference we make in the world. It’s a lovely story. Watching the great Frank Capra film has become a holiday tradition for many.

The first major radio adaptation aired on March 1947, on CBS’s Lux Radio Theatre, just two months after the movie’s theatrical release.Two more followed in 1949 and 1951. For years, Irish Repertory produced a charming version in its intimate W. Scott McLucas Studio Theatre. This is not that rendering.


Andrew Rannells & Titus Burgess

Joe Landry’s interpretation is yeoman- like. Unlike Irish Rep’s iteration, the writer gives us no glimpse into the lives of the radio actors, something that added verisimilitude and interest.

Santo Loquasto has designed a BIG, beautiful broadcast studio of which, excluding a piano and sound station (sound effects man Leslie Bloome is fun to watch), perhaps five feet of apron is utilized. Wigs (Luc Verschueren for Campbell Young Assoc.) all look fake.

Actors play numerous roles.

The only cast member fully inhabiting his character, Andrew Rannells actually reminds one of Jimmy Stewart who originated the role. George Bailey appears to be a guileless young man, wearing his heart on his sleeve, living on the fumes of dreams. Many poignant moments are of Ranells’ making and he works without book.

Harry Hamlin (announcer, Mr. Potter and others), on the other hand, never gets his face out of his. (book.) Hamlin’s Mr. Potter is neither cantankerous nor very villainish, a lost opportunity. In fact, all Hamlin’s roles merge.


Andrew Rannells & Megan Hilty

Tituss Burgess is a sweet Clarence, though he could be more timid. The actor trots out several credible, droll accents in other roles.

Megan Hilty is best as George’s wife, Mary. A two-handed scene where she doesn’t recognize him because he’s never been born is moving. Welcoming her husband back at the end, she seems as sincere as home fires.

Lisa Rinna almost manifests street walker Violet, but really only comes alive as George’s little daughter, Zuzu.

Direction (Jerry Zaks) is rote. Where’s the man who added clever stage business and deft timing to the Neil Simon plays?

Stream the film.

Photos by Matthew Murphy & Evan Zimmerman
Opening: Lisa Rina, Andrew Rannells, Harry Hamlin, Megan Hilty, Titus Burgess

It’s a Wonderful Life- A Live Radio Play
Adapted by Joe Landry
Based on the story “The Greatest Gift” by Philip Van Doren Stern
Directed by Jerry Zaks
Broadhurst Theatre 235 West 44th Street
Through January 3, 2027