By Alix Cohen
The narrator (Christopher Fitzgerald) is a self admitted thug. Dublin Gangster Joe Murray kept him on payroll to intimidate/scare people who didn’t toe the line. Violence is second nature, all in a day’s work, a literal shrug.
Two betrayals drove the battered protagonist to another country from where he shares his tale in a dim pub, Guinness on the table.The first was desertion by promiscuous girlfriend Greta in favor of his boss. He can’t get her out of his blood. The second, a brutal double-cross by Murray himself that cost everything but the Narrator’s life.
Sent to threaten warehouse owner Patrick Mitchell who refused to pay protection money, the hired enforcer found himself a target. His detailed story of ambush, beating, and murder; of flight – Mitchell’s wife and daughter in tow; of innocent victims, blood and ash, is regaled so dispassionately we forget it’s a confession.
Playwright Conor McPherson writes in chiaroscuro – contrasts between light, shadow, and deep dark creating depth, dimension, and drama. The narrator’s poetic descriptions, moments of tenderness, even flickers of what might’ve been are stealthily braided in. McPherson seduces. You may wince, but despite cold blooded cruelty, won’t turn away.The Good Thief is never less than riveting.
Many know Christopher Fitzgerald as a musical theater actor, though his full résumé is all inclusive. This should forever dispel the assumption he excels only in that genre.

The brilliant performance is utterly natural. Recollection appears to occur here and now. Thoughts and feeling migrate across Fitzgerald’s face conjuring events. The actor stands when restless, gestures only as an extension of feeling, pauses when struck by a something, and addresses audience without self consciousness.
He wears the Narrator’s class and experience like a timeworn shirt. Irish accent is impeccable. (Dialect Coach- Liz Hayes) We see a man exhausted and a little confused by unforeseen outcome.The latter signals as finely calibrated an emotion as I’ve observed onstage.
Director Justin Waldman has crafted a wholly credible human being. McPherson’s tale is told in vignettes bracketed by palate-cleansing light and slight music as if pausing to gather thoughts. Pacing is beautifully wrought.
Scenic Designer Wilson Chin’s pub is pitch perfect- brick walled with a narrow window through which Lighting (Jen Leno) displays nuanced change. Costuming (Jess Goldstein) personifies the character right down to his shoes. Sound (Drew Levy) offers rain and snippets of evocative music.
According to Catholic Gospel, Jesus was crucified between two criminals. One mocked him, saying, in effect, if he really was the Messiah, he should save himself—and them.
The other criminal rebuked him: “We are punished justly, for we are getting what our deeds deserve. But this man has done nothing wrong.” Then he turned to Jesus and said: “Jesus, remember me when you come into your kingdom.” That thief, “the good thief”, was assured a place in Paradise.
Photos by Carol Rosegg
The Good Thief by Conor McPherson
Featuring Christopher Fitzgerald
Directed by Justin Waldman
Irish Repertory Theatre 132 West 22nd Street
Through December 20, 2026
https://irishrep.org/whats-on/the-good-thief
