Review by Alex Eichholz . . .

How do brilliant, hot stars burst forth from a cardboard moon without burning it into oblivion? With significant new twists of gender, Second Stage has brought back that old perennial The Fantasticks, which opened tonight at the Hayes Theatre. It breathes fresh air into a musical that first opened off-Broadway in 1960. Its run was historic, closing in 2002 and, after only a four-year break and a change of venue, returned for another run that lasted until 2017. Now, sixty-six years after it premiered in the 153-seat Sullivan Street Playhouse in Greenwich Village, it is at long last making its Broadway debut, albeit in a 597-seat house (the smallest on Broadway and perfect for this gentle little musical). Director and choreographer, Christopher Gattelli has been entrusted with the mountainous responsibility of preserving the integrity and delicacy of the original while also maintaining relevance in the current social and cultural landscape. It’s a pleasure to state it’s a success.

Its authors, Harvey Schmidt (music) and Tom Jones (book and lyrics), lived to see the show become part of theatrical history. However, Schmidt, who died in 2018, had no part in his partner’s rewrite, which was first staged in 2022, the year before Jones’s death at age ninety-five. Here we have a reimagining of the young lovers as two boys and their scheming fathers as mothers, allowing for an exploration of new horizons of young love, parental interference, and the inevitable heartache, and headache, of growing up.

With respect for the simplicity of its original staging, Gattelli establishes the perfect tone for what’s to come from the get-go. The opening confetti and subsequent bursts that are sprinkled through the show have been retained. This charming touch establishes a playfulness and levity that flow through the evening. Even something as simple as the conductor’s opening bow feels like the purest welcome to the production’s fairy-tale-like universe.

Ahmad Simmon’s Mute is essential to the storytelling, functioning as a silent stagehand, ever-present in the action. It’s charming to see him manipulate the environment, adding kinetic energy to each transition and giving the character a personality beyond his limited means of communication. As El Gallo, Zane Phillips captivates with a soft yet commanding Golden Age musical theatre voice, though his acting occasionally lacks the same conviction. Rather than fully inhabiting the character’s manipulative authority, Phillips sometimes appears too conscious of playing the part and even comes across a little green, particularly when navigating moments that exist more in the shadows.

Ahmad Simmon as the Mute in The Fantasticks.

Nathan Levy’s Lewis (formerly Luisa) and Maxim Chlumecky’s Matt are the romantic heart and soul of the piece. They possess a glittery chemistry that can’t help but be compared with the two young stars of the hit TV series Heated Rivalry. The way their voices blend, particularly in the songs “Metaphor” and “Soon It’s Gonna Rain,” makes for something truly special. Their relationship feels earnestly boyish rather than overly feminized, allowing the characters to retain their youthful awkwardness, enthusiasm, and naivety. Levy’s Lewis sees the world with an eccentric romantic imagination, especially in his declaration that he is eighteen and that something happens to him every day. Chlumecky, meanwhile, brings an intellectualism to Matt, whose rigid logic cannot begin to account for the overwhelming irrationality of his love for Lewis. His shouted declaration, “I’m eighteen years old. And every day something happens to me,” is both amusing and touching. It’s impossible not to cheer for their bliss while knowing what lurks around the corner of first love. Together, they make the central romance feel spontaneous and hopeful.

The production further grounds itself in the maternal pairing of Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer’s Mildred and Ruthie Ann Miles’s Bessie. Their chemistry is undeniable, and their comic timing is without peer. Kritzer’s strong-willed, flower-obsessed Mildred pairs exceptionally well with Miles’s practical, veggie-crazy Bessie. Their rendition of “Never Say No” is a highlight, but act two’s “Plant a Radish” is, somewhat surprisingly, the emotional crux of the show. They make these mothers feel like real, loving moms and offer a glimmer of warmth to every audience member who holds their inner child close.

Ruthie Ann Miles as Bessie and Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer as Mildred in The Fantasticks.

Rounding out the cast with broad vaudeville turns are David Patrick Kelly as The Old Actor (Henry) and Kevin Del Aguila as The Man Who Dies (Mortimer). Total pros, they land the laughs they’re after with ease.

Jones’s gender switch lets the boys’ romance be treated with refreshing matter-of-factness, made apparent by lines like “We live happily ever after! No reason in the world it can’t happen exactly like that.” And Matt’s declaration that he will not simply marry according to his mother’s expectations, but will marry “in my own particular way,” makes the revised material feel purposeful rather than cosmetic. The queer redirection feels unforced, preserving the show’s theatrical innocence while allowing its emotional perspective to evolve.

Gattelli’s direction and choreography complement Jones’s changes with great care. The movement is expressive yet not too elaborate, and the second act tap sequence is particularly effective. Jason Sherwood’s scenic design is similarly effective in its minimalism. The wall remains the production’s central visual piece, and the surrounding environment has a tactile and grounded feeling. Notably, greenery appears during moments of true romantic connection, subtly suggesting that love encourages growth, and is just as quickly packed up when that love is on the line. Linda Cho’s costumes further home in on the production’s visual storytelling with color and pattern motifs that distinguish the characters by using warm and cool tones as well as soft and rigid shapes. Jen Schriever’s lighting completes the picture, giving the production its subtle shifts in atmosphere without overwhelming Sherwood’s restrained scenic elements. The blues and violets are particularly striking against the whites when they are introduced, creating deliciously rich visuals.

Ultimately, this wonderful production of The Fantasticks succeeds because it understands that updating a classic doesn’t mean abandoning its heart. The reminder that “gardens keep on growing” becomes more than a charming horticultural observation, reflecting the necessity of allowing young people to develop beyond their parents’ expectations and, in this show’s case, old art to find new life outside its previous confines. Like the flowers that gradually emerge throughout the evening, this revival finds new life in familiar soil.

At the Hayes Theatre, 240 W 44th Street, NYC, now through February 7, 2027. For further information, please visit The Fantasticks.

Photos by Joan Marcus.

Headline photo: Nathan Levy as Lewis and Maxim Chlumecky as Matt in The Fantasticks.